Archive for August, 2009

What was Bill Thinking?

Saturday, August 15th, 2009

I have no idea what was going through Bill Carpenter’s mind when he was quoted in the August 5,2009 BPP article about a suburban RBTL venue.

As per the BPP, Bill said “Without having a specific site in mind I told them that we’d be willing to come to the table. I think it’s a great venue to have. I think it would fit in our community in many ways so I think it’s worth considering.”

Think traffic. Think no open space near an expressway entrance. Think no mention of this type of need in the about to be approved Comprehensive Master plan.

I think he is just off the wall on this.

Campaign Contributions – Christa

Monday, August 3rd, 2009

I have been doing some research using the New York State Board of Elections campaign finance database available through the link http://www.elections.state.ny.us/DisclosureReports.html# .

If you want to roll your own, the link http://www.elections.state.ny.us/CFDownloads.html leads to the full database downloads by filing period. Looking up the filer’s account numbers you want and doing some database work, you can really find out a lot.

Although I can do it and have done it in the past, I’m lazy and have been sticking to the disclosure reports recently.

As an exercise, I looked up contributions by ‘Christa’, uploaded it as both html and text to my machine and then started to work in a spreadsheet.

Stripping everything away but filings by Christa Construction, Christa Development and David Christa with addresses either of Victor, Fairport or Williamsville (Christa Construction apparently has an office there)  leads to some interesting data.

Here are the yearly totals:

2000 5950
2001 11200
2002 19900
2003 6800
2004 8200
2005 14250
2006 69980
2007 58965
2008 47698
2009 16900
259843

Beginning in with July 2006, all local campaigns had to file through the State Board of Elections so it is not a surprise that the amounts jump in 2006.

Here are all the Christa contributions as of August 3, 2009 since the online system started in 1999 sorted by recipient and then date:

300 02/27/09 ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS OF
500 08/18/02 CITIZENS FOR JOSEPH ROBACH (SENATE)
300 03/17/03 CITIZENS FOR JOSEPH ROBACH (SENATE)
350 07/19/05 CITIZENS FOR JOSEPH ROBACH (SENATE)
500 07/17/08 CITIZENS FOR JOSEPH ROBACH (SENATE)
250 10/09/08 CITIZENS FOR JOSEPH ROBACH (SENATE)
1000 04/26/04 CITIZENS TO ELECT JOHN BONACIC
250 03/30/09 COLLINS FOR OUR FUTURE
3000 01/14/03 COLUMBUS CIRCLE AGENCY, INC.
150 07/20/06 COMM ITTEE TO ELECT MARYANNE
150 11/01/06 COMM ITTEE TO ELECT MARYANNE
200 06/15/09 COMMITTEE TO ELECT JAMES E. SMITH
250 03/12/09 COMMITTEE TO ELECT JUDGE JOHN
1000 11/14/05 COMMITTEE TO ELECT MAZIARZ STATE
1000 04/19/06 COMMITTEE TO ELECT MAZIARZ STATE
500 07/28/08 COMMITTEE TO ELECT MAZIARZ STATE
500 09/07/06 COMMITTEE TO RE-ELECT ASSEMBLYMAN
500 05/12/08 COMMITTEE TO RE-ELECT ASSEMBLYMAN
1000 01/07/05 COMMITTEE TO RE-ELECT JUDGE
200 09/26/06 COMMITTEE TO RE-ELECT JUDGE PAUL KEHOE FOR SUPREME
250 07/05/00 ERRIGO FOR ASSEMBLY
500 07/27/00 ERRIGO FOR ASSEMBLY
150 08/23/02 ERRIGO FOR ASSEMBLY
250 06/28/07 FRIENDS OF ANTHONY J. DANIELE
2000 09/10/08 FRIENDS OF ASSEMBLYMAN BILL
250 05/25/06 FRIENDS OF BILL CARPENTER
500 07/10/07 FRIENDS OF BILL CARPENTER
500 03/31/09 FRIENDS OF BILL CARPENTER
250 05/15/02 FRIENDS OF BILL MULROW
2500 03/10/06 FRIENDS OF BOB DUFFY
2500 03/26/07 FRIENDS OF BOB DUFFY
200 03/01/04 FRIENDS OF BRIAN KOLB
1000 09/12/05 FRIENDS OF CHERYL DINOLFO
250 06/30/08 FRIENDS OF DIANE LAVALLEE
500 02/22/07 FRIENDS OF DISTRICT ATTORNEY MIKE
2000 10/10/02 FRIENDS OF JIM ALESI
2500 08/26/04 FRIENDS OF JIM ALESI
2600 10/05/05 FRIENDS OF JIM ALESI
250 07/16/07 FRIENDS OF JIM ALESI
2600 09/21/07 FRIENDS OF JIM ALESI
1000 06/22/01 FRIENDS OF JOHN FASO
2000 08/15/05 FRIENDS OF MAGGIE BROOKS
10000 03/03/06 FRIENDS OF MAGGIE BROOKS
6000 08/01/06 FRIENDS OF MAGGIE BROOKS
1000 07/31/07 FRIENDS OF MAGGIE BROOKS
250 08/24/07 FRIENDS OF MAGGIE BROOKS
1000 09/12/07 FRIENDS OF MAGGIE BROOKS
1000 07/20/00 FRIENDS OF PATAKI
5000 07/06/01 FRIENDS OF PATAKI
5000 02/21/02 FRIENDS OF PATAKI
5000 02/21/02 FRIENDS OF PATAKI
1000 10/21/02 FRIENDS OF PATAKI
150 06/06/07 FRIENDS OF RONALD W. NESBITT
200 01/15/09 FRIENDS OF RONALD W. NESBITT
500 03/09/06 FRIENDS OF SUPERVISOR JOHN T.
350 10/10/06 FRIENDS OF WAYNE ZYRA
500 09/10/08 FRIENDS OF WAYNE ZYRA
3000 08/29/07 FUND FOR REPUBLICAN MAJORITY
300 10/04/05 GENERAL BUILDING CONTRACTORS
300 05/31/06 GENERAL BUILDING CONTRACTORS OF NEW
300 01/23/07 GENERAL BUILDING CONTRACTORS OF NEW
300 01/30/08 GENERAL BUILDING CONTRACTORS OF NEW
1000 03/31/06 JEANINE PIRRO FOR ATTORNEY
1000 05/05/06 JEANINE PIRRO FOR ATTORNEY
1000 10/03/01 MARY DOYLE FOR SUPREME COURT
200 10/05/01 MARY DOYLE FOR SUPREME COURT
3000 03/25/00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3000 03/08/01 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
2500 08/16/02 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
2500 08/31/02 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3000 03/03/03 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
1000 03/21/04 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3500 08/31/04 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
1500 04/01/05 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
1500 04/01/05 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3000 03/01/06 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3500 07/19/06 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3000 02/22/07 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
3000 03/04/08 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
1000 04/30/08 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
1000 09/27/08 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE
1250 10/13/06 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
1000 10/26/06 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
1250 01/04/07 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
1250 04/16/07 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
1250 05/03/07 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
1250 07/11/07 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
1250 10/05/07 MONROE COUNTY DEMOCRATIC
2000 08/17/05 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
5000 03/17/06 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
6000 09/05/06 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
6000 11/14/06 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
15000 04/18/07 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
6000 07/06/07 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
1700 07/20/07 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
10000 10/22/07 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
15000 02/04/08 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
6000 05/20/08 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
2000 07/23/08 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
11000 09/26/08 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
15000 04/14/09 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN
700 06/19/08 MONROE COUNTY REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
1000 09/13/05 NEW YORK REPUBLICAN STATE
5000 05/12/06 NEW YORK REPUBLICAN STATE
1500 03/28/07 NIAGARA COUNTY REPUBLICAN
2500 07/20/07 NIAGARA COUNTY REPUBLICAN
2500 07/31/08 NIAGARA COUNTY REPUBLICAN
198 03/05/08 NIAGARA COUNTY REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
15000 10/26/06 NYS SENATE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN
500 07/03/03 NYS SENATE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE
150 04/04/06 PENFIELD REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
180 04/04/06 PENFIELD REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
165 03/26/07 PENFIELD REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
250 10/29/07 PENFIELD REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
300 09/27/07 PERINTON REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE-VICTORY
500 05/06/08 SHERIFF PATRICK O’FLYNN CAMPAIGN
1000 08/09/00 THE COMMITTEE FOR A STRONG
1000 10/22/01 THE COMMITTEE FOR A STRONG
1000 10/01/02 THE COMMITTEE FOR A STRONG
200 10/17/00 THE COMMITTEE FOR A STRONG ECONOMY
200 06/12/09 WEBSTER REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE
259843

Judge for yourself how evenly split between Democrats and Republicans Christa entities make their contributions.

According to the New York State Board of Elections page http://www.elections.state.ny.us/Contributions.html :

The New York State Election Law places aggregate calendar year limits on the amount of political contributions that can be made by individuals and corporations to New York State candidates and committees, as follows:

  • An individual may contribute up to a total of $150,000.00 in a calendar year.
  • A corporation may contribute up to a total of $5,000.00 in a calendar year.
  • Each affiliated or subsidiary corporation, if a separate legal entity, has its own limit.

Note that the table above covers several different entities and people so in order to see if these limits have been violated, you need to go back to the original page and total the individual entities up for each year. I’ll leave that as an exercise for the reader.

How much in consultations and contracts has Christa entities gotten during this period? I have no idea.

Of course, correlation is not causation – but I’m suspicious.

Illegal Village Signs – 8/3/09 followup

Sunday, August 2nd, 2009

As of last Thursday, the Pierson signs at Sutherland and Monroe had come down but the Brizee sign was still up. As per the Village, the responsible employee is on vacation and won’t be back until Monday.

Since the Trustees get notified about a complaint, well the Pierson signs are gone.

My intent was just to mention the Village temporary signs before going on to Town temporary signs but there is more. My photos, the property lines as shown on the County mapping site (http://www.mappingmonroe.org/mmb)/ and the Village Code ( go to the Village website http://www.villageofpittsford.org/; use the link in the first paragraph, enter 168-6 as the section number you want to look at) indicate that as of last Thursday you would be hard pressed to find a legal real estate sign anywhere in the village!

Take the signs on the south side of Monroe east from Main to the bank. these include the for rent sign near the corner as well as several for lease/sale signs further east.

Blue line is emphasizes property line

Blue line is emphasizes property line

Click on the image to see it blown up or go to the mapping site and look for yourself.

The property line is flush with the buildings, not out towards the sidewalk.

What is going on with code enforcement in the Village? If you understand, please comment below. I don’t have a clue.

And this is a newly revised ordinance as of 4-28-2009!

That for sale sign on the north side of Monroe further east- within the right of way and with the additional part on top, my estimate is that it is over the four square feet limit. The signs along Jefferson are apparently all in the right of way. Shoen Place – Flour Mill for rent sign is legal since the property goes essentially across the street but with the one on the grain tower, there are two signs on the parcel with only one permitted.

Pittsford Dairy has a temporary sign most days between the sidewalk and the curb, in the right of way.

While the Village Zoning Board of Appeals can allow exceptions, it looks like most temporary signs in the village don’t meet code.

Then there are the contractors signs allowed by 168-6 A(3). My guess is the intent of the new law was that these should be set back 10 feet, too, but the law doesn’t read that way. In any case they should be on the property being worked on, not in the right of way and certainly not in the right of way down at the corner.

The ones I saw last week didn’t seem to comply except for the one at Danielle’s which might and I mean might not be in the right of way. And whose house was being painted a few weeks back by the painter that had a sign at Monroe and Washington?

If these signs are gone or more legally placed by the time you look, great! But don’t let anyone claim they weren’t there – I have the pictures to prove it.